I couldn’t quite put into words what I felt after listening to Sean Tobin’s song John Wayne. It took a moment to realize that was the point. The song ended, and the silence that followed lingered, leaving its mark in a way the music itself didn’t need to explain. That sense of emotional residue sits at the center of Tobin’s songwriting, music that invites you in, holds you for a moment, and leaves room behind once it’s gone. It’s in that quiet space, between certainty and doubt, where this conversation begins.
Raised on the New Jersey shore and now based in Nashville, Sean Tobin is an alt-folk songwriter drawn to stories that live in the grey. His songs pull from Jersey rock, Irish folk, and American roots, but are anchored by a deep focus on empathy, lived experience, and unanswered questions. Treating each record as its own emotional journey, Tobin writes less to provide conclusions and more to explore what it means to sit with uncertainty, growth, and change.
SNQLX: How did growing up on the New Jersey shore shape the way you approach storytelling in your songwriting, both emotionally and thematically?
SEAN: Growing up on the New Jersey shore comes with inescapable musical influences. Songs by Springsteen, Southside Johnny, and more ‘Jersey Sound’ creators are played in every bar from Highlands to Cape May. What I didn’t realize until I came into my own songwriting is how not only the sound embedded itself in my creativity, but the stories told through music. There’s plot. There’s characters. There’s lives lived in a 3 minute span. That’s what I wanted to do, all while entertaining a crowd.
SNQLX: When you reflect on your earliest releases, what do you understand now about your voice or instincts as a songwriter that wasn’t clear to you at the time?
SEAN: I cringe when I hear my early stuff. But I think that shows growth. I wouldn’t be where I am now without them. I know now that I’m trying to philosophize in a way that I don’t think every writer is. I’m trying to ask the hard questions, and I’m trying to be okay with the fact that there might not be a clear answer. I’m trying to come to terms with the grey.
SNQLX: What changes for you creatively when you write from perspectives outside your own experience, and how does that affect the emotional weight of a song?
SEAN: I think empathy is my biggest strength and my biggest hurdle. I try my best to put myself in another person’s shoes, which can result in feeling things that I myself might not “need” to feel. But I think it makes me stronger as both a writer and as a human being. It’s the most important process in fiction, because it makes the stories real. It makes the weight true.
SNQLX: How do you navigate writing about family, work, and legacy in a way that feels honest without feeling overly exposed?
SEAN: I do my best to balance absolute truth with respect. I ask myself if the story I’m telling– the moral– is more important than the repercussions of audience perception. That said, I often change names, places, and events just enough that they can’t be pinned to anything too true, if necessary. If it’s a positive light shed on character, I might change a thing (Eugene, Hail the Carpenter, etc.), but at the end of the day, it’s a question of greater good.
SNQLX: When building a record, what role does emotional sequencing play for you, and how intentional is the journey you want a listener to experience from beginning to end?
SEAN: Emotional sequencing plays a massive role for me. I consider myself a nerd when it comes to this, and I probably spend more time than I should deciding track order. I’ve even written new songs to bridge emotional gaps within a record, just to appease myself. I want each record to feel like a life all its own. I want there to be a spectrum of emotion, but in a way that doesn’t feel jarring.
SNQLX: How has living and working in Nashville influenced your relationship with songwriting as a craft, rather than just an emotional outlet?
SEAN: The Nashville scene has forced me to write more and to write well, purely because of the caliber of other writers that live here. And that’s exactly why I moved here, to get better. I no longer think about writing purely as “will this make my performance more entertaining,” but “will this song make an impact worth preserving.” I care more about what I’m saying (and how I say it) than I ever have.
SNQLX: Are there subjects or emotional spaces you intentionally avoid writing about, and what informs that decision?
SEAN: No. The more uncomfortable I am, the better. That’s where the good stuff happens. That doesn’t mean I’ll always release what I’ve written, but writing has always been for me first, audience second.
SNQLX: What do older songs reveal to you now about the person you were when you wrote them?
SEAN: It’s funny, I can triangulate my own emotional growth through my songwriting. I can see who I was at 21, 25, and so on. My early 20’s were teenage nostalgia, mid-20’s about familial legacy, and my 30’s seem to be leaning toward societal philosophy. I can see where my values were, my world-views, even my politics. And they continue to change, as they should.
Editor’s Note
The written interview captures reflection. The conversation that follows captures presence. What you’re about to watch isn’t a repeat of what you’ve read, but a continuation — the thoughts, pauses, and personality that live between the words.
Discover more from SONIQLOOX | Indie Music Stories
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
